LeftColumnBK

Council Chooses Plastic Over Paper; Haulman Makes Committee Appointments

Williamsburg city council met Thursday afternoon in the first regular session with two new council members and a new mayor and vice-mayor. They looked at preliminary year-end numbers, heard what committees they would serve on and chose to ditch paper agendas and instead buy iPads for council members starting right away.

Fiscal year 2010 ended June 30, and Finance Director Phil Serra gave council a preliminary report. He told council the city had budgeted revenues at around $32.1 million, and had brought in $31.6 million, about $481,000 under budget. He said this was primarily due to lodging and room taxes, other taxes, and interest earnings all below expectations due to the recession.

Expenditures were $29.4 million, $2.7 million below budget. The savings were thanks to the 911 call center consolidation and other cost-cutting measures, but departments all did what they could to cut spending, Serra said, which helped keep expenditures below target.

Serra also said the operations surplus came in at nearly $674,000, which sounds like a lot but is less than prior years, he pointed out. The surplus is only about two percent of revenues, or enough to cover about eight days of operating expenses.

Capital project expenditures came in about $2.3 million over revenues, due to the municipal building expansion and other projects.

There are still some other revenues and expenses that will come in over the next few weeks, Serra said, that might change the numbers slightly. Council will get a complete analysis in the fall.

Vice Mayor Paul Freiling said in the current economic climate, he believes the numbers “show great care on the city’s part not to be collecting more money than it needs” and also shows great fiscal responsibility on the part of staff.

New members Scott Foster and Doug Pons asked a few questions about the future financial plans for the city, which Mayor Haulman said was a discussion council would have during its budget discussions later in the year.

Mayor Haulman also announced some appointments to boards and commissions during the meeting. Architectural Review Board member Daniel Quarles, an attorney, will be moved to the planning commission to fill Doug Pons’ seat, and City Green developer Demetrios Florakis will take Quarles’ seat on the ARB.

The full appointments to boards and commissions are available here.

Haulman also announced decisions on appointments to various committees in the city, including his selection of Scott Foster to serve as representative with the Greater Williamsburg Chamber and Tourism Alliance. Doug Pons has long been involved in Triangle tourism through his various roles with the Williamsburg Hotel Motel Association and has also long been a critic of the Alliance’s handling of various aspects of marketing the city as a tourist destination, but he was not selected for the committee.

Instead, Haulman appointed Pons to the School Liaison Committee. Haulman will serve on the Williamsburg Area Destination Marketing Committee, another tourism promotion group in the city (it is typical for the city mayor to be the city’s representative here).

Haulman will serve on a total of 12 committees (generally because the mayor needs to fill most of these roles); Vice Mayor Freiling will serve on three, Judy Knudson will serve on two, and the two new councilmen will serve on one each. The full list of committee appointments is available here.

Information Technology Director Mark Barham brought along an Apple iPad (a small, looseleaf paper-sized touch-screen computer) to show council. He also gave a presentation on how the technology works and why he thinks it would be a good idea for council to stop using paper agendas and go to using the iPad.

He said about 34,000 pieces of paper were used each year to print agenda packets for council at a cost of about $2,000. An iPad would run about $614 per council person (including software). These would pay for themselves in about 18 months, he estimated.

The device has excellent graphics, Barham said, is not bulky, has an application that allows council members to write notes and highlight areas of interest in documents, and is a fully functional computer with internet access.

After asking a few questions about lifespan of the devices, battery life and usage, council voted unanimously to stop printing copies of the agenda and start using the iPads.

Other business
Council also unanimously voted on adopting a new ordinance that would allow residents on streets in the city to limit parking by non-residents if a majority or homeowners sign a petition requesting the limitation.

Right now, in order for streets to have limited non-residential spaces, two criteria must be met: vehicles regularly occupying parking spots must exceed 75 percent of available spaces, and the average number of non-residential parked cars should exceed 25 percent of parked vehicles.

Due to a high number of non-resident parked vehicles on non-restricted roads like Goodwin Road, staff suggested the new ordinance so homeowners could have a say outside what already exists in city code. Freiling suggested a slightly lower percentage of consensus for the petition (still more than 50 percent), and staff will revise the language to reflect this in the new ordinance.

Council requests

Due to discussions on the issue among council members, the mayor asked staff to gather information and create an avenue of public discussion on the proposed Surry coal-fired power plant, which both Pons and Foster said they opposed during their campaigns. Staff will have the information ready by next month.

Foster said he had heard from some city residents that council meeting times were not convenient for those who work standard nine-to-five hours, and he asked if meeting times could be changed. Haulman directed staff to compile a list of pros and cons on the change so council could review it.

Comments  

 
+1 #18 Guest 2010-07-12 20:45
It is funny how people compare netbooks to iPads. A netbook's screen is small and square and you have to scroll a lot to view a PDF and/or document. An iPad is tall and better made for viewing a PDF and/or document at 100%. Congratulations on posting your comments from your netbook. I'm sure the little bitty comment box fit nicely in your little bitty screen.

And as far as the whole iPad needing a 3G connection, doesn't Merchants Square and beyond have free wifi? Was that a waste of Taxpayer dollars back in 06? I'm having a business meeting on Wednesday in Merchants Square with a client from Newport News and a client from New Kent because of the good food and wifi. The wifi was the deciding factor by the way. Boo out-of-town business! Hisss.

iPhone is like $200 or more for the phone and $99/mo for the service. Everyone and their mom has one of those. So, a $600+ iPad is much cheaper than a $1,200+ a year iphone bill.

And, yes, things drop and break. So, do copiers and printers. Also, have you ever bought printer ink and seen the price tag? It is not just paper they are saving the cost on.

Seriously, I moved here from Virginia Beach. If you want to cry about City Council spending money, live there for a year. Ask people who live there how many times they go to that $202.5 million dollar Pavilion Center the city had to build. I mean it really pulls in the business from October - April when its nothing but cold wind and sand at the Oceanfront. Then, add another $35 million for the Sandler Arts Center to give the local arts orgs a place to call their own. You'll soon start to realize that spending a few grand on iPads is pretty tame. That is like the property tax on ONE $350k house in Virginia Beach! Booooo low property taxes in Williamsburg. Hisss on the wasteful spending that keeps them low.
Quote
 
 
+5 #17 Guest 2010-07-12 19:37
Wow, everyone jump on the City for trying to be innovative. Barham made a case for the cost of paper/toner/dis tribution and an investment idea with an ROI of 18 months. Sure paper is recyclable, but the point wasn't to make the treehuggers sing kumbaya, it was to save money. Kudos for a government actually trying to make a sound business decision.

The person that brought up the Netbooks makes a valid point (although uses $1100 instead of $600 - that price also included the markup/note software). Not knowing how technically savvy the council is, I'd image it'd be a lot easier to train someone on a ipad than a netbook, not to mention trying to read long documents on a netbook would be horrible, and then marking up on top of that.

We'll see in a year or two if the numbers add up, but give them props for trying something. I live in JCC and their IT has been so backwards for years. It took them forever to get some of their services to be paid online, and you still have someone behind the scenes processing the payment. Williamsburg has been on top of technology for their citizens with a far smaller budget than JCC.

And to the person talking about spending money for the building during a bad economy. I'd image this wasn't a spur of the moment plan, and had been in the design/planning phases for quite awhile. In any case, sound strategy is save when times are good, spend when times are tough (ya know, that whole jobs thing?)
Quote
 
 
0 #16 Guest 2010-07-10 15:40
As I drove by our new City building going up on Francis Street, this guy wondered how in the heck WE could be spending all that $$$ during such an economically depressed period?....for more space that could be used already in the current municipal building? Can you tell us, please, Mayor and City Council?
Quote
 
 
+9 #15 Guest 2010-07-10 08:44
Council will still have to deal with the fractious tourism industry regardless of the appeasing appointments. The low level of tax receipts will dictate increasing accountability for donations to CW and the ALLIANCE and all Council Members will be required to weigh in on tourism.
Quote
 
 
+3 #14 Guest 2010-07-10 07:31
My netbook for under$300 does everything an I pad will do for $1100. This local government is off to a very shaky start. Ipads may be in vogue, but when does a city council need to be in vogue?

Sent from a netbook. I hope I have communicated clearly to the council.
Quote
 
 
-1 #13 Guest 2010-07-10 05:31
It would have been a far better move by Haulman to appoint Pons to one of the tourist positions to help bring that industry together. Instead, he has made a lot of people who voted for Pons angry in snubbing tourist interests.
Quote
 
 
+2 #12 Guest 2010-07-09 22:25
Drop a piece of paper and nothing happens: drop an iPAD and it's a $600+ loss. If you hold one you'll realize they are slippery little suckers so you'll need a $50 case to wrap it in BUT even that doesn't protect it from breaking. Then you'll need a special case with padding plus all the fun "apps" etc. etc. etc. Of course to round out it's usefulness each one will need a communications capability that comes with a monthly charge since wi-fi is so 'yesterday'. The machine itself will be obsolete long before the 18 month "break even" time occurs so you'll have to get upgrades and/or new models. All this accomplishes is to replace recyclable paper without gaining productivity... .but we'll look cool!! Children the country, the state and this county are in serious financial straits but who cares, right???
Quote
 
 
-2 #11 Guest 2010-07-09 20:45
I just moved to Williamsburg 2 weeks ago so imagine my surprise to hear that at a time when revenues are down, the council bought themselves Ipads. I appreciate the desire to reduce paper costs that repeat at every meeting by making a one-time technology expenditure but isn't there something more affordable than the Ipad? Don't most of these members already have laptops and blackberries they could use at the meetings?
Quote
 
 
-5 #10 Guest 2010-07-09 17:32
Technology always fails. ;-)
Quote
 
 
+5 #9 Guest 2010-07-09 14:06
By eliminating paper agendas, which paper is a renewable and recyclable item. How long will it take to see a savings for the City? Or do we have a group of children just wanting new toys?
Quote
 

Add comment

WYDaily invites you to join the community conversation. We expect civil discourse here. Personal attacks on others, indecent language and bad manners in general are unwelcome.


Security code
Refresh

Talk of the Town

Talk of the Town