LeftColumnBK

Proposed Farm Store In Norge Passes Planning Commission

A new farm supply store is one step closer to joining several others in Norge, though one business owner pleaded with planning commissioners Wednesday not to approve the application.

Tractor Supply Company, of Brentwood, Tenn., aims to open up a new 19,000-square-foot farm supply store with an additional 21,200 square feet of outdoor sales space near Farm Fresh in the Norge Center Shopping Center. The stores supply products for a “rural lifestyle,” from welders and generators to animal care products, as well as work clothes, animal feed, lawn and garden supplies, riding mowers and power tools.

John Fleet, who runs James River Fleet Brothers - about a mile from the proposed store - and sells many of the same products as Tractor Supply Company, told planning commissioners the national business “is the WalMart of the industry.”

He argued that this would hurt his business and several other similar businesses nearby because shoppers had the impression big box stores have lower prices. His approximately 40 employees’ jobs could be at risk, he said.

Fleet also argued that the stores were usually large and unattractive, and “it’s hard to make that design fit into the character” of the area. His business, he argued, had to follow much stricter guidelines when it was established a few years ago.

Commissioners pointed out those businesses directly adjacent to Community Character Corridors (like Fleet’s) have stricter guidelines than the Tractor Supply Company site, which is more than 500 feet from the corridor.

Commissioner Rich Krapf noted the commissioners’ job “is to make recommendations on land-use cases… it is not within our purview as to whether something is a smart business decision or not.”

Commissioners Michael Maddocks and Joe Poole agreed with Krapf. Poole said he was mindful of Fleet’s concerns, but the application has a good setback from the road and is adjacent to a large retailer, and the land is already designated for a business use.

Commissioners voted unanimously to approve the application, with an amendment to the features of the fencing around the business. There will be a large, black or green chain-link fence around the property, but the front facing the road will be made of vinyl and colored to match.

Other business

Commissioners also approved the Special Use Permit for the flea market at Colonial Towne Shopping Center. The applicant noted that if the shopping center, owned by the Ware family, is sold, the lease with the flea market would be terminated. The center is currently under negotiation.

Commissioners also approved an SUP for the construction of an auxiliary gym at Jamestown High School.

 

 

Comments  

 
+4 #12 Guest 2010-12-04 11:39
Tractor Supply is a great store and I hope it does well. I also hope that Fleet Brothers continues to provide the great products and services that it does, and I also hope that Jamestown Feed & Seed is able to continue providing their unique offerrings too. I don't think a little competition is going to be a disaster. If anything it will help all of those outfits as they will have to refine their business practices to continue being profitable. In the end the greatest benefit will be for the consumers as we will be able to have more options to choose from related to goods,services, and prices. It's understandable that some folks want to limit competition or growth as it may have an effect on their business, but here in america that's what we call free market capitalism and in the world that we live it's pretty hard to beat.
Quote
 
 
+2 #11 Guest 2010-12-03 18:16
"Commissioner Rich Krapf noted the commissioners’ job “is to make recommendations on land-use cases… it is not within our purview as to whether something is a smart business decision or not.”

Once again, Commissioner Krapf gets is right.
Quote
 
 
-9 #10 Guest 2010-12-03 14:32
Who cares about the empty buildings on richmond road. It's not like you are talking about a great area anyway. Besides the vacant buildings will go great with all the vacant homes in that are that are vacant.
Quote
 
 
-5 #9 Guest 2010-12-03 13:43
Marilla Cuthbert and OldTimer have it dead wrong. They misunderstand the basic marketplace concept of over-saturation , which this is a clear case of. And then we all get stuck with the empty storefronts that come as the result. These blighted unused properties in turn diminish the values of all properties nearby.

Simply letting the pure marketplace have its way is not the smart approach to growth. Marketplace forces must be smartly managed to bring value to an area.

Is OldTimer going to buy the blighted, empty storefronts himself? If not, the dopey old fool should put a sock in it because his simpleton notion of how a local economy works will bring ruin to lots of local people. Duh.
Quote
 
 
+13 #8 Guest 2010-12-03 12:26
I shop at Fleet Brother's regularly and will continue to do so. The employees make the business - they are friendly and very knowledgeable. Their customer service is topnotch and if I have to spend a few more $ for that than so be it.
Quote
 
 
-8 #7 Guest 2010-12-03 12:13
Just another case of our local officials letting any large operation in to our area regardless of the potential damage to our local businesses. Look at Monticello Road, it is a disgrace. Big money always wins!!
Quote
 
 
+2 #6 Guest 2010-12-03 12:02
Where I grew up more or less resembles James City and there was a Tractor Supply. The store seemed to be run ethically and treated customers with respect. And frankly, a number of its customers would not have been comfortable at the more glitzy shopping areas at the other, more urban, end of the county.

I don't buy this attempt at demonization the local business owner was attempting. Sounds to me like he was just trying to protect his income.

Let the marketplace work its wisdom.
Quote
 
 
+11 #5 Guest 2010-12-03 11:19
Legal right or not, the marketplace will decide if the business is good for the community. Don't shop there if you don't like it.
Quote
 
 
-5 #4 Guest 2010-12-03 09:53
There is another farm/garden supply store being built up by Andersons Corner in Toano. So that'll be three of these types of stores within a few miles of each other.

In the end, some will fold and leave their empty buildings as yet another abandoned, blighted shopping center in the county.

It is staggering how utterly stupid these county officials are. Don't they understand that is foolishness is destructive to the county? Why don't they get it? What on earth are their goals for the county?!? Do they have absolutely no brains?!?
Quote
 
 
-8 #3 Guest 2010-12-03 09:20
If the planning commission does not have the legal right to say "No, thank you...we don't think this business will be good for our community"..... .who does???
Quote
 

Add comment

WYDaily invites you to join the community conversation. We expect civil discourse here. Personal attacks on others, indecent language and bad manners in general are unwelcome.


Security code
Refresh

Talk of the Town

Talk of the Town