LeftColumnBK

ALL Closes With Bittersweet Ceremony

The final completion ceremony from the Academy for Life and Learning was short on pomp and circumstance, but full of joy and love.

Forty-eight students completed seventh and eighth grade at the school Thursday with a one-hour ceremony marked by jubilant performances, heartfelt speeches and group hugs. It was a bittersweet celebration for the faculty and students because after four years, the alternative education program is coming to an end.

The Williamsburg-James City County School Board approved the elimination of funding for the program in March, instead planning to hire student advancement coaches for the division’s three middle schools. The coaches will be tasked with identifying and supporting struggling students, developing improvement plans and tracking students’ progress. Board members said that the coaches should be able to reach more at-risk children than the 48 enrolled at ALL. The budget for the coaches is also lower; ALL’s budget for this school year was $570,000 and the coaches, plus program changes, were budgeted for $300,000.

ALL opened in 2007 under the leadership of Principal Anthony Mungin. Its students attended school in four trailers on land rented from Eastern State Mental Hospital until this past fall, when the program moved to the annex of James Blair Middle School. A staff of four teachers worked one-on-one with students on their core subjects, while an additional behavior specialist taught the students about respect and responsibility. Most students who attended the school had previously failed classes and/or their Standards of Learning tests. This year, ALL’s students achieved the school’s best scores on the reading SOL tests, and two students had perfect scores on their math SOLs.

Administrators said earlier this year that they wanted to find a way to help students improve in their “home schools,” rather than be sent off-site to a different program. They also said that students who integrated back into their schools after leaving ALL were struggling to keep up their newfound academic success. Two students who graduated from ALL in 2010, Jessica Norwood and Andrea Millhouse, confirmed that they did struggle this year when they attended Lafayette High School and Jamestown High School, respectively.

“Academically, I was passing, but socially it didn’t go so well,” Millhouse said after the ALL graduation ceremony. “I missed my friends from ALL and my teachers who could help me.”

Norwood said that during her time at ALL she passed her math SOL for the first time, and while her grades slipped this year, she still managed to pass her SOLs. She thought part of why ALL worked was that it removed her from peer pressure and conflicts at her school. “At ALL, everyone has been through something like you’re going through,” she said.

At Thursday’s ceremony, graduating students delivered speeches about the students they used to be, the students they have become and the students they will be. Rising ninth-grader Amber Anderson said her teachers at Toano Middle School let her slack off, and she had a bad habit of judging people. “I couldn’t stand Toano, so I made a decision for me and I came to ALL,” she said. “The student I am now is the student I never thought I’d be.” She went on to say that the program works because the students “have to pick each other up,” and added, “I’m sad no one else will have this experience.”

Dakota Holland, who will start ninth grade next fall, shared how her ALL family supported her when her father was sent back to prison earlier this year. She said that as a student, she lacked focus, but her teachers challenged her. “They pushed me so far I thought I’d fall, but I didn’t,” she said. “I found my balance and scored a perfect 600 on the math SOL.”

Parents also said the ALL experience engaged them in their children’s education. “They taught us that we brought these children into the world and that it was time to step up and be the support system they needed,” said Veronica Colon, who was recognized for her volunteer work and advocacy for the program.

After the ceremony, teachers Alissa Brown and Kristin Dwyer said their time at the school will change the way they teach at Berkeley and Hornsby middle schools next year. Dwyer said that when she focused on helping the students believe in themselves, academic success followed. Brown said she will try to give individualized attention. “[The experience] has helped us to narrow in on what the kids need,” she said.

In his final speech as principal, Mungin choked back tears as he told the audience his own success story. He was given up by his teenage mother when he was three years old, and spent his elementary and middle school years in special education classes. When he was an eighth grader at James Blair, his special ed teacher told him college isn’t for everybody, but his ninth grade English teacher, Susan Miller, thought he was capable of more.

She told WYDaily in 2009 that he was sharp, articulate and motivated. “Nothing about him matched a profile of someone you would have labeled as remedial,” she said.

He went on to take advanced classes, attend college and become an educator. On Thursday, he told the audience, “I believe there are a lot of Anthony Mungins in WJCC.” His final message was one of self-reliance.

“There will be people who will not support you, who will not believe in you,” he said. “That’s why you have to believe in you.”

Comments  

 
+6 #20 Guest 2011-06-21 13:55
I searched but couldn't locate the numbers of students for each year who attended Academy for Life and Learning. What were they, please? Thanks.
Quote
 
 
+9 #19 Guest 2011-06-20 18:23
:sad: "It Takes a Whole Village to Raise a Child"

"It Takes a Whole Village to Raise a Child" which means the responsibility of raising a child does not lie in the parents alone, but also with the extended family and in some cases the whole community, the Academy for Life and Learning (ALL) somehow fit that ole’ proverb saying. You had parents that were engaged in their children’s education, teachers and a principle Mr. Mungins, which was caring and dedicated to each student’s education and life success. Children today need an atmosphere created for them to succeed, and ALL gave them, those students, that someone and something to help them into the next step of life. This environment offered them a challenge that pushed, encouraged and understood the need for them to becoming productive citizens. If many of us would have received this type of specialized attention during our early school years, imagine how much further in life we would have been.

No man, woman, or family is an island, and ALL offered a community that supported the parents as well as the students. We’d like to think we live in a place where people care about others -- where people pitch in to help when things get rough -- where our children are receiving the education and attention they need to succeed, but we all know this isn't always what we experience. Instead of our public schools system, where the children may have felt and /or/ found themselves alienated looking for someone to pay or give them close attention, ALL provided them that hope for a better education and way of life. One year ago I was asked to be a guest speaker at the school, and it gave me a great snap shot of the ALL program. During that encounter with the students at ALL, I became very impressive with what the teachers were accomplishing, and developing within these students. What our kids need today, ALL provided, which is one-on-one attention, focused educational needs, the right thing, in the right place, at the right time. It’s truly unfortunate that this program will not be around to benefit more future students.

r/ Walk
Quote
 
 
+8 #18 Guest 2011-06-20 13:03
You know.....I was always told, IF ITS NOT BROKE, DONT FIX IT! I am really sad that the cities budget was so broke, they decided to take it out on a REMARKABLE program that was all but broken! My son was one of the many students that completed the program this year. He may not have Aced every course, but he definately came a long way from where he was previously! Mr. Allen was one of the BIGGEST influences in my sons life this year. He was truely a GOD sent ANGEL! If not for him, I wouldve lost my son a long time ago. He will BLESS each and every student he comes in contact with in the future. Mr. Mungin and the teaching staff were also GREAT! The care and compassion these people showed to our children was unbelievable! It pains me that the uprising middle school children who WILL NEED this kind of help and attention are being robbed of the same opportunity. Im dumd founded as to WHY IN THE WORLD WJCC SCHOOLS WOULD LET GO OF SUCH AMAZING, COMPASSIONATE AND CARING PEOPLE! This decision will do more harm than good. Its sad that only the mear voices of our community know this, but our CITY & SCHOOL BOARD DO NOT! THANK YOU SO MUCH TO EACH AND EVERY PERSON AFFILIATED WITH ALL! THANKS TO YOU, MY SON, JOHNATHAN, STANDS A CHANCE AT HIS FUTURE!!!!
GOD BLESS EACH OF YOU!
Quote
 
 
-10 #17 Guest 2011-06-20 10:22
What defines success? Students had to be admitted to the program by Mr. Mungin, they had to leave their home schools, and there is no evidence that they brought better skills with them when they re-integrated into regular school. It is no surprise that those involved enjoyed the benefits of extremely low teacher to student ratios and excelled. But WJCC doesn't have unlimited resources. ALL was not a sustainable program. It served too few students and cost too much money. The new program of coaches has yet to be tested. Parents: be viginlant and get your kids enrolled with the coaches. Maybe it will work just as well for less money with the added benefit of serving more students in their home schools.
Quote
 
 
+11 #16 Guest 2011-06-20 09:04
Forward looking school divisions are looking for ways to expand opportunities for their students. They realize that one size does not fit all, and a dollar spent now on education will be returned many fold in the future. Especially when it comes to the difference between a child graduating or not graduating down the road. If after two years at ALL these at-risk students were able to successfully resume their education at the high school level, the program was doing exactly what is was designed to do.

If the closing of all is indicative of other decisions being made by our board and administration, then our schools are suffering from a crippling lack of leadership.
Quote
 
 
+12 #15 Guest 2011-06-20 08:57
The completion ceremony was extremely bittersweet for me!! We all worked so hard to fight to keep the program alive. Since last year, getting the parents and students to find the courage to stand up infront of the School Board was a challenge but they went up there with strength and truth and the board members just didn't get it!!! Yeah shame on them!! Our new Superintendent so called admires parent invloved and support, so why didn't he see that this program did just that!!! As for his Assistant Superintendent, and you all know who referring to, Believe me we will be monitoring how these "coaches" idea pans out. You haven't heard the last of us! Not by long shot!!!
Quote
 
 
+13 #14 Guest 2011-06-20 08:42
The Tindall Family shared with me the wonderful graduation moments of the 2011 8th grade class. We always ask, "Can You Touch Someone" and no doubt these children were touched by being motivated, encouraged, and given insight. These are truly ways in which our children can be touched and my nephew truly benefited from this warm setting.
Quote
 
 
+11 #13 Guest 2011-06-19 20:49
In Dr. Mathews resume he references several published documents that focused entirely on Alternative Education and doing away with outdated methods that did not meet student needs. Later in his career is seemed like he lost his "vision" for an Alternative High School which he came to WJCC with exactly that in mind. What happens behind closed doors is always speculation, but I can only imagine. But at some point he realized Williamsburg may have been and maybe still is in denial....denia l that we have 30 percent of students in 3rd grade to 12th grade who are at risk for failing school, but will likely fail in life. That WJCC has a high percentage of disadvantaged students, who do not live in the gated communities, but in the cottage communities that may or may not have electricity or running water. That these kids come from a world of self sufficiency and survival skills are kicked into high gear. These kids need more that what is offered in the main schools. Student coaches who come from a sheltered life of a two parent, high income home, have nothing in common with these kids. How in the world are they going to relate to a student who has a mom in jail and a father who they never knew? What the coaches will do is feed the ego of the administrator who without first doing a pilot program to gather real actual data and having any historical data, has sold yet another ill prepared program to The Bobble Heads that call themselves the WJCC Board of Education.

In WJCC is not at all about the students, it is all about the EGO of those who are sitting FAT and happy in the James Blair Administrative Building. I would love to run that office! Everyone would be paid on performance, and would actually have to do research and become immersed in the process of the quality improvement process school wide. And I would be looking for those at the top of the heap to be involved at every level. That would then separate Hands On Walkers, from the Bobble Head Talkers!

For example, Mr. Mungin and his staff are Walking the Walk. And what I have personally witnessed is outstanding results. Unlike Admin who is Talking the Talk and all I hear is BLAH, BLAH, BLAH!
Quote
 
 
+13 #12 Guest 2011-06-19 15:23
To: Janice is right-
You sound like a school board member or Dr. Lindsay. First of all, everyone knows Dr. Mathews help create The Academy for Life and Learning and made sure it was in the superintendents budget before he left. He was a big supporter of Mr. Mungin and saw the value of the school.
Second, Mrs. Jones excelled in a program that was created to help her. IT IS DIFFICULT FOR ME TO REACH STUDENTS WHO ARE WOEFULLY LOW WHEN I HAVE 21 STUDENTS IN mY CLASS AND I'M RESPONSIBLE FOR TEACHING INFORMATION THREE GRADE LEVELS HIGHER THEN THEY ARE.
I saw a lot of students who were behavior problems go to All and it made it easier for me to teach and for the students in class to learn. It was a win-win situation for everyone. To those who think that, "my child will never go to that school so it doesn't matter to me" you are very neive! Your child will be in school and class with disruptions and behavioral issues. You earned this for Sara and Jonny because you didn't get involved.
As for the coached instead of All, we should have been talking about having both. Board members never had a child who would benefit from all so they only know what they know, not much. As soon as we see this board make decisions for all kids, then we will start having a school system that we should have in this affluent town of ours.
When you have something that is working, you talk about how you can expand it. Our board and administration, present included, never did this!
Quote
 
 
-6 #11 Guest 2011-06-19 14:19
Quoting Janice is right:
The failure of the school board to halt the dismantling of WJCC alternative education programs and vocational programs by superintendent Matthews is inexcusable. Thank goodness they finally woke up and got rid of him. It will take years to recover. I have mixed feelings about the ALL program. It appears to work well for the students attending, but I wonder if the Ms Jones comment, #5 below, is the same for other former ALL students. Were we disservicing these students by isolating them? Maybe the coaches will be more effective. These students have to learn how to thrive in real-world situations.

Dr. MATTHEWS ACTUALLY SUPPORTED THE ALL ACADEMY !!!
Quote
 

Add comment

WYDaily invites you to join the community conversation. We expect civil discourse here. Personal attacks on others, indecent language and bad manners in general are unwelcome.


Security code
Refresh

Talk of the Town

Talk of the Town